TL;DR: A phenotypic selection analysis revealed that selection due to male‐male competition during pollination was capable of delaying flowering date and widening corolla tubes by 0.22 and 0.24 standard‐deviation units, respectively, in a single generation.
Abstract: I measured phenotypic selection of floral traits through both male and female functions of the hermaphroditic flowers of Ipomopsis aggregata (Pursh) V. Grant subsp. aggregata (Polemoniaceae). Fluorescent powdered dyes were used to track movement of pollen by hummingbirds and to measure pollen delivery to individual plants as well as pollen receipt. A phenotypic selection analysis revealed that selection due to male-male competition during pollination was capable of delaying flowering date and widening corolla tubes by 0.22 and 0.24 standard-deviation units, respectively, in a single generation. Several floral traits were highly correlated with each other. Multivariate selection analysis suggested that selection through male function directly favored late flowering as well as a sexual expression characterized by a short pistillate phase and long corollas. Selection intensities through male and female functions were of similar overall magnitude during the pollination stage of the life cycle, but different traits were favored, and selection sometimes acted in opposing directions. In 1985, selection through female function favored increased time spent in the pistillate phase and exserted stigmas (unlike selection through male function). As a result, individual plants varied greatly in functional gender. Plants that had exserted stigmas and narrow corollas and that spent a disproportionately long time in the pistillate phase achieved greater pollination success as females, while plants with the opposite traits achieved greater success as males. Moreover, female pollination success tended to increase, and male pollination success to decrease, with time spent in the pistillate phase, supporting a critical assumption of sex-allocation theory. Selection in the populations studied fluctuated from year to year and was highly sex-specific.
TL;DR: The family as a whole was monophyletic with no support for the segregate family Cobaeaceae, and several well supported groups allowed us to test hypotheses of relationship within Polemoniaceae.
Abstract: Nucleotide sequences of the plastid encoded gene matK were examined for their potential utility in phylogenetic analyses within angiosperm families. Sequences 661 bases in length were obtained from twenty species of Polemoniaceae. Phylogenetic analyses resulted in four equally parsimonious trees with a consistency index of 0.70. Several well supported groups allowed us to test hypotheses of relationship within Polemoniaceae. The segregation of Ipomopsis and Allophyllum from Gilia was supported by the placement of each in distinct groups separate from a group of four species of Gilia. Several strongly supported groups include genera now placed in different tribes. There was no support for the current separation of temperate Polemoniaceae into two tribes. The tropical genera were resolved as basal and paraphyletic within the family. The family as a whole was monophyletic with no support for the segregate family Cobaeaceae. Sequences of matK, a gene that had not been used previously for phylogenetic analyses, provided a sufficient number of reliable characters for phylogenetic analysis within Polemoniaceae. Pairwise comparisons of matK and rbcL sequences of the same taxa were performed. Sequences of matK varied at an overall rate twice that of rbcL sequences. Substitutions at the third codon position predominated in rbcL sequences, while in matK substitutions were more evenly distributed across codon positions.
TL;DR: In the hummingbird‐pollinated herb Ipomopsis aggregata, selection through male function during pollination favors wide corolla tubes, and the phenotypic selection differential was 80% higher for the effect on pollen exported per visit, suggesting that this is the more important mechanism of selection.
Abstract: In the hummingbird-pollinated herb Ipomopsis aggregata, selection through male function during pollination favors wide corolla tubes. We explored the mechanisms behind this selection, using phenotypic selection analysis to compare effects of corolla width on two components of male pollination success, pollinator visit rate and pollen exported per visit. During single visits by captive hummingbirds, flowers with wider corollas exported more pollen, and more dye used as a pollen analogue, to stigmas of recipient flowers. Corolla width was less strongly related to visit rate in the field, and had no direct effect on visit rate after nectar production and corolla length were controlled for. Moreover, the phenotypic selection differential was 80% higher for the effect on pollen exported per visit, suggesting that this is the more important mechanism of selection.
TL;DR: An approach to studying pollinator-mediated selection in plant hybrid zones, using two species of Ipomopsis (Polemoniaceae) as a model system, is illustrated and phenotypic selection gradients are calculated and the form of selection in the hybrid zone is characterized.
Abstract: Clines across hybrid zones can be produced by several forms of natural selection. We illustrate an approach to studying pollinator-mediated selection in plant hybrid zones, using two species of Ipomopsis (Polemoniaceae) as a model system. We measured visitation to flowers in natural and experimental populations by two major types of pollinators, hummingbirds and hawkmoths, at up to three different spatial scales. Using measures of pollinator visitation, we calculated phenotypic selection gradients and characterized the form of selection in the hybrid zone. Hummingbirds overvisited Ipomopsis aggregata compared with Ipomopsis tenuituba and morphological hybrids at all spatial scales, especially the largest scale of kilometers. These responses may depend in part on the presence of other hummingbird-visited plants in the community. Hummingbird behavior produced directional selection favoring wide corolla tubes and intense red coloration. Hawkmoths, in contrast, overvisited plants with narrow corolla tubes. Wh...
TL;DR: The results suggest that pollinator-mediated selection could act on color, shape, and nectar separately, and that hummingbird selection favoring red flowers may result from past experience and, thus, may depend on the ecological context.
Abstract: Apparent associations between flower color and type of pollinator might be explained by correlations between color and other floral traits, rather than by narrow pol- linator preferences for color. To explore this possibility, we obtained flowers varying nat- urally in color, nectar reward, and morphology, from a hybrid zone between Ipomopsis aggregate and L tenuituba in western Colorado, United States. We used aviary and field experiments to study preferences of hummingbirds for unmanipulated flowers and for flow- ers in which we experimentally dissociated color from nectar reward and morphology. Hummingbirds preferred red flowers of L aggregate, which contain superior nectar rewards and have relatively broad corolla tubes, relative to flowers of L tenuituba, which are white, contain small nectar rewards, and have narrow tubes. There was no evidence of flower constancy. When presented with flowers differing only in color, birds showed a spontaneous preference for red. However, this preference could be reversed by making white flowers more rewarding than red. When plants of both parental species and their hybrids were placed in an array in the field, with all flowers painted red, hummingbirds preferred to visit the more rewarding, wider tubed L aggregate. These results suggest that pollinator-mediated selection could act on color, shape, and nectar separately. Experimental manipulations that dissociate these traits are essential to distinguish direct from correlated selection. Also, hummingbird selection favoring red flowers may result from past experience and, thus, may depend on the ecological context.