FNA Mapping

Abstract: Systematic testis fine needle aspiration (FNA) mapping has been proposed as an adjunctive or alternative diagnostic procedure to biopsy to determine the presence of spermatozoa within infertile testes. This study related testis histology to the global presence or absence of spermatozoa in the same testes determined by FNA cytology. Testis biopsies and FNA mapping were performed in 87 infertile, azoospermic men. A mean of 1.3 biopsies and 14 FNA sites were taken per patient. Biopsies were assessed by recognized histological patterns of normal, Sertoli cell-only, hypospermatogenesis, early and late maturation arrest, sclerosis as well as mixed patterns that included at least two of these histologies. FNA cytological specimens were assessed for sperm presence by an experienced cytologist. Overall, spermatozoa were found by FNA mapping in 52% of patients. A comparison of histology and FNA findings revealed that pure patterns of Sertoli cell-only and early maturation were associated with a very poor likelihood of sperm detection (4-8%). In contrast, patients with other pure pattern histologies or mixed patterns had high rates of FNA sperm detection (77-100%). Similar to reported testicular sperm extraction (TESE) findings, sperm detection with FNA shows wide variation depending on testis histology. Unlike most TESE reports, however, some histological patterns generally reflect a more global testicular dysfunction and poorer likelihood of sperm identification, suggesting the possibility that these phenotypes have a genetic origin. Systematic testis sampling with FNA offers additional geographical information about spermatogenesis that routine biopsies lack and can further guide couple decision-making in severe male factor infertility.

Abstract: It is widely thought that human testicles affected by unilateral pathology will have greater impairment of spermatogenesis than the otherwise unaffected testis. This study reviewed records of non-obstructive azoospermic (NOA) and virtually azoospermic (NOVA) men with associated testicular pathology who underwent testicular fine needle aspiration (FNA) mapping. Concentration of spermatozoa found in each testis was analysed to discern sperm-lateralization patterns in affected and unaffected testes. A total of 1098 FNA sites from 56 men (32 varicocele, 16 cryptorchidism, three epididymo-orchitis, two mumps orchitis, three torsion) were analysed. Overall, 38 patients (68%) had spermatozoa detected in at least one testis. Most men (68%) had equal proportions of FNA sites showing spermatozoa from both testes, 29% had more spermatozoa from the unaffected testis and 3% had more spermatozoa from the affected testis. Significantly fewer sperm-positive sites were observed on the affected (272 out of 752) than unaffected side (164 out of 346) (P < 0.0001, chi-squared test). When assessed by FNA mapping, most NOA and NOVA men with known unilateral testis pathology will have equal proportions of spermatozoa in both testes. However, when sperm production differs between sides, the unaffected side is much more likely to have spermatozoa. This information may be used to refine sperm-retrieval strategies in selected patients.

Abstract: We sought to evaluate the ability of fine-needle aspiration (FNA) mapping to find sperm and to guide sperm retrieval after failed microdissection testicular sperm extraction (micro-TESE) in nonobstructive azoospermic men. In this study of consecutive male infertility cases, interventions included testicular FNA mapping and subsequent sperm retrieval. Outcomes included the frequency and location of found sperm on FNA maps after failed micro-TESE and the salvage sperm retrieval success. Among 548 patients undergoing FNA mapping from 2010 to 2016, 82 men with previous micro-TESE procedures were identified. The mean time between micro-TESE and FNA mapping was 2.2 years. A total of 2825 (1424 on right and 1401 on left) sites were mapped. At least one site revealed mature sperm in 24 (29.3%) of 82 men with prior failed micro-TESE procedures. There was an equal likelihood of detecting sperm in either testis (6.1% right; 5.7% left; P = 0.58). Digital “heat maps” revealed differences in sperm findings within the testis with mature sperm more likely found in the testis periphery rather than centrally. Fifteen (62.5%) patients subsequently underwent sperm retrieval procedures guided by FNA maps. Sufficient sperm were retrieved in all cases, and in 10 (66.7%) of 15 cases, extra sperm were frozen for future use. In a significant proportion of failed micro-TESE procedures representing the largest study to date, sperm were detected by FNA mapping and could be reliably retrieved through FNA map-guided surgical sperm retrieval. When present, sperm were more likely to be found in the testis periphery rather than centrally with FNA mapping.