Get your Journal of Comparative Economics paper right the first time: a ready-made structure with the right abstract and citations, so editors see your science, not formatting slips.
4.5
Authored by Sumalatha Gangadhar | Published on 17 August, 2026
Submitting to Journal of Comparative Economics goes smoothly when your draft already matches the journal's own rules. Editors screen new manuscripts against the Journal of Comparative Economics guide for authors before peer review, so formatting, structure, and required statements should be right on the first draft rather than repaired during upload. This template sets that structure up for you.
It is a manuscript shell aligned to Journal of Comparative Economics. It covers front matter, the abstract the journal expects, a body organized to the journal's article types, and a reference list in the journal's required style. Confirm current scope and article types on the Journal of Comparative Economics journal page before you draft.
Prepare the title, authors, affiliations, and ORCID iDs. Write the abstract to the journal's rule and word limit, organize the body to the article type, and apply the required reference style from the first citation. Complete every declaration (ethics, competing interests, funding, data availability) the Journal of Comparative Economics guide for authors lists, and cite figures and tables in order.
The common failure modes are formatting or reference style that does not match the guide for authors, missing required statements, and an incomplete portal checklist. Clear all three against the Journal of Comparative Economics guide for authors before you submit.
The shell mirrors what editorial staff check first: article-type fit, the abstract rules, required declarations, and the journal's reference style. For more detail see the author resources. When your draft is ready, upload it through Editorial Manager.
| Element | J Comparative Econ requirement |
|---|---|
| Abstract | Unstructured. The guide states: 'A concise abstract should briefly state the purpose of the research and the main results. An abstract is often presented separate from the article, so it must be able to stand alone.' No word limit specified, no mandatory headings, no differentiation by article type |
| Main text | Organize sections for the chosen article type; no single overall word limit is stated in the accessible guide |
| Declarations | Ethics approval/consent as applicable; competing interests; funding; data availability |
| Figures/tables | Publication-ready; cited in order |
| Supplemental | Upload separately when used |
| Keywords | At least 1 standard JEL code and up to 5 additional keywords (total: 1 JEL code + 1-5 keywords) |
| References | Author-date style (Harvard-like). In-text citations as 'Smith (1992)' or '(Smith et al., 1969)'. Reference list in alphabetical order by author surname. Journal titles not abbreviated. Example: 'Buch, Claudia M., Heinrich, Ralph P., Pierdzioch, Christian, 1999. The value of waiting: Russia's integration into the international capital markets. Journal of Comparative Economics 27, 209-230.' |
| Peer review | Single-blind. The guide specifies 'Blind review' and requires that 'the title page, abstract, and manuscript should omit the authors' names and affiliations' and that 'this information is not seen by reviewers,' indicating reviewers do not know author identities (single-blind) |
| Submission | www.editorialmanager.com/YJCEC/default.aspx |
Read the Journal of Comparative Economics guide for authors once before drafting and once before upload. Draft the abstract after results are stable. Set the reference style before adding citations. Keep a cover letter that states your contribution and fit to Journal of Comparative Economics in under a page.
Skim two or three recent J Comparative Econ papers to calibrate depth and figure style. Make the novelty clear in the first two pages. Deposit data and code when the policy on the Journal of Comparative Economics journal page requires it. Disclose any preprint or conference version with identifiers in the cover letter.
Do one focused pass against the Journal of Comparative Economics guide for authors: scope, length, reference style, required declarations, and figure quality. Then submit through Editorial Manager.