1. How does nonbinary gender generation help understand Bava Metsia 84a?
Nonbinary gender generation provides a lens to understand the mechanics at play in Bava Metsia 84a by challenging the binary understanding of gender. The text suggests that Yohanan, a figure in the passage, does not fit into the traditional male gender categories and is visibly femme. This challenges the binary understanding of gender and highlights the cultural and classificatory multiplicity of species and gender. The rabbinic frameworks that allow for gender variation create the context for understanding Yohanan's gender. The text also discusses the rabbis' forensic gaze and linguistic reticence, which disrupts the binary understanding of sexgender duality. Nonbinary gender generation helps denaturalize the inevitability of cisgender and challenges the assumptions and assignments of gender. It allows for the exploration of other femme, queer, nonnormate, and nonbinary bodies and circuits of desire and generation. This perspective provides a deeper understanding of the mechanics at play in Bava Metsia 84a and the cultural context of the time.
read more
2. What are the origins and influences of the incantation bowls in the context of Jewish communities of Persian Babylonia?
The incantation bowls are cultural products of the Jewish communities of Persian Babylonia, with their immediate generators being rabbis and incantation scribes, and their clients being the Jewish women. The story of the Jewish women rising to the surface and beholding the sage sitting at the entrance, resulting in the conception of beautiful children, bears traces of Palestinian conception concepts but also incorporates Zoroastrian notions of mythic conception. The search for origins and influences can lead to a narrow view of creative work generation, but it is important to consider the combination of visual triggers and waterseed conception in the Palestinian midrash. The virgin birth fantasy, present in the Bundahisn, has Galenic resonances and has been discerned in various rabbinic sources, highlighting the patrilineal model of generation. The incantation bowls reflect the exposure of the rabbinic storytellers and transmitters to a variety of Zoroastrian ideas, stories, and rituals. The generative practices of the rabbis' Yohanan and Adam, as well as the Zoroastrian characters, are not presented as models for human propagation but offer a glimpse into social classes broader than those of the religious scholars. The appeal of the not exactly cis Rabbi Yohanan and their unconventional reproductive methods to a rabbinic audience, as well as the ambivalent attraction of Lilith to the clients, women, and men who commissioned the incantation bowls, showcases the disruption of formalized relationships and the transgression of a cisgender sex binary. The incantation bowls open the parameters of the possible beyond the supposedly obvious circuits of sexuality, the 'natural,' and reproduction, offering a realm of species and sexual strangeness, and genuine reproductive uncertainty.
read more