Scispace (Formerly Typeset)
  1. Home
  2. Journals
  3. Resources Conservation and Recycling
  4. 2019
  1. Home
  2. Journals
  3. Resources Conservation and Recycling
  4. 2019
Showing papers in "Resources Conservation and Recycling in 2019"
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2019.03.045•
Circular economy indicators: What do they measure?

[...]

Gustavo Longaray Moraga1, Sophie Huysveld1, Fabrice Mathieux, Gian Andrea Blengini, Luc Alaerts2, Karel Van Acker2, Steven De Meester1, Jo Dewulf1 •
Ghent University1, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven2
01 Jul 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: A classification framework to understand what indicators measure is proposed and none of the analysed indicators focuses on the preservation of functions.
Abstract: Circular Economy (CE) is a growing topic, especially in the European Union, that promotes the responsible and cyclical use of resources possibly contributing to sustainable development. CE is an umbrella concept incorporating different meanings. Despite the unclear concept, CE is turned into defined action plans supported by specific indicators. To understand what indicators used in CE measure specifically, we propose a classification framework to categorise indicators according to reasoning on what (CE strategies) and how (measurement scope). Despite different types, CE strategies can be grouped according to their attempt to preserve functions, products, components, materials, or embodied energy; additionally, indicators can measure the linear economy as a reference scenario. The measurement scope shows how indicators account for technological cycles with or without a Life Cycle Thinking (LCT) approach; or their effects on environmental, social, or economic dimensions. To illustrate the classification framework, we selected quantitative micro scale indicators from literature and macro scale indicators from the European Union 'CE monitoring framework'. The framework illustration shows that most of the indicators focus on the preservation of materials, with strategies such as recycling. However, micro scale indicators can also focus on other CE strategies considering LCT approach, while the European indicators mostly account for materials often without taking LCT into account. Furthermore, none of the available indicators can assess the preservation of functions instead of products, with strategies such as sharing platforms, schemes for product redundancy, or multifunctionality. Finally, the framework illustration suggests that a set of indicators should be used to assess CE instead of a single indicator.

874 citations

Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2019.104498•
Towards sustainable development through the circular economy—A review and critical assessment on current circularity metrics

[...]

Blanca Corona1, Li Shen1, Denise Reike1, Jesús Rosales Carreón1, Ernst Worrell1 •
Utrecht University1
01 Dec 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: This review aims to identify the foundations of circularity metrics used so far and their applications, evaluate the validity of currentcircularity metrics, based on predefined requirements and a CE definition anchored in the sustainability concept, and provide recommendations on how to measure circularity.
Abstract: The circular economy (CE) is perceived as a sustainable economic system where the economic growth is decoupled from the resources use, through the reduction and recirculation of natural resources. In the shift towards the CE, quantifying the circularity of products and services (or their contribution to the CE) is crucial in designing policies and business strategies, and prioritizing sustainable solutions based on evidence. New circularity metrics are being developed for that purpose, but they often present contradiction in both form and content, which contributes to confusion and misunderstanding of the CE concept. This review aims to map methodological developments regarding circularity metrics for products and services, in order to: (1) identify the foundations of circularity metrics used so far and their applications, (2) evaluate the validity of current circularity metrics, based on predefined requirements and a CE definition anchored in the sustainability concept, and (3) provide recommendations on how to measure circularity. The literature search provided a wide variety of CE metrics being developed and applied (seven measurement indices, nine assessment indicators and three assessment frameworks). However, none of them are addressing the CE concept in full, potentially leading to undesirable burden shifting from reduced material consumption to increased environmental, economic or social impacts. Additionally, new metrics under-represent the complexities of multiple cycles and the consequences of material downcycling. Circularity metrics intended to sustainable decision making should be comprehensive enough to avoid burden shifting, and clearly indicate how the benefits of recycling are allocated between the primary and secondary products.

676 citations

Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2018.10.009•
A literature review on green supply chain management: Trends and future challenges

[...]

Ming-Lang Tseng1, Shamimul Islam2, Shamimul Islam3, Noorliza Karia2, Firdaus Ahmad Fauzi2, Samina Afrin4 •
Asia University (Taiwan)1, Universiti Sains Malaysia2, ASA University Bangladesh3, University of Chittagong4
01 Feb 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this article, a review of the literature in green supply chain management (GSCM) published from 1998 to 2017 and presenting insights and directions for future research is presented. And the authors identify influential authors, top journals, top contributing countries, and contribution by disciplines.
Abstract: This study aims to review the literature in green supply chain management (GSCM) published from 1998 to 2017 and presenting insights and directions for future research. The study collects data from Scopus and ISI Web of Science databases and objectively selects 880 papers and conducts metadata analysis. In addtion, 236 papers from ISI Web of Science is analyzed to present the insights along with the classifications of the literatures based on content analyses, which comprises of conceptual development, drivers and barriers, collaboration with supply chain partners, mathematical and other optimization models, and assessment of green supply chain management practices and performance. The study finds that research on drivers or barriers analysis of green supply chain management reveals a declining trend while there is a growing trend of applying mathematical optimization models for enhancing decision making in pursuit of environmental performance. Moreover, the study finds a consistent growth in the evaluation of green supply chain management practices and performance. Though, the concept of green supply chain management started gaining popularity among academicians from the beginning of the 20th century, this study finds a sharp growth of publications on the topic after 2010 until now. This study identifies influential authors, top journals, top contributing countries, top contributing institutions and contribution by disciplines. This study presents a comprehensive but straightforward conceptual model of green supply chain management. The findings and future research directions of the study offers a new avenue for further exploration and contribution to this discipline.

670 citations

Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2018.09.031•
Pursuing green growth in technology firms through the connections between environmental innovation and sustainable business performance: Does service capability matter?

[...]

Yudi Fernando1, Yudi Fernando2, Charbel José Chiappetta Jabbour, Wen Xin Wah3•
Universiti Malaysia Pahang1, Binus University2, Universiti Sains Malaysia3
01 Feb 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors investigated the mediating effect of service innovation capability on sustainable organizational performance and environmental innovation and found that eco-innovations unlock better sustainable performance, while service innovation can also act as a business strategy to create barriers to new entry by competitors.
Abstract: In response to greater environmental awareness among stakeholders, companies have become increasingly interested in practices such as eco-innovation. Despite the expanding literature on eco-innovation, scholars have so far paid little attention to the study of eco-innovation and its impact on business sustainability, particularly considering the mediating effect of service innovation capability. To fill this research gap, this study extends the concepts of green business by investigating an original conceptual framework, which proposes that the capacity for service innovation has a mediating effect on the relationship between sustainable organizational performance and environmental innovation. This conceptual framework is subjected to empirical testing, implemented through a survey involving 95 Malaysian firms which use green technology. Data is collected through both postal and online questionnaires and analyzed through structural equation modeling using partial least squares. Respondents for this paper were identified using the directories of MyHijau (2013) and the Malaysia External Trade Development Corporation, 2014. The results suggest that: (1) eco-innovations unlock better sustainable performance; (2) service innovation capability has a partially significant positive mediating effect; (3) service innovation capability ultimately benefits companies by allowing them to differentiate through an emphasis on value creation; (4) service capability can also act as a business strategy to create barriers to new entry by competitors. Thus, eco-innovation and service innovation capability tend to represent significant intangible resources and enable an organization to achieve long-term objectives, competitive advantage and business sustainability. To date, this is the first study relating eco-innovation, service innovation capability and sustainability performance in the Malaysian corporate context and using a specific sample of companies that make use of green technologies. © 2018 Elsevier B.V.

555 citations

Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2019.01.023•
Green innovation and firm performance: Evidence from listed companies in China

[...]

Dayong Zhang1, Zhao Rong2, Qiang Ji3•
Southwestern University of Finance and Economics1, Nanjing Audit University2, Chinese Academy of Sciences3
01 May 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this article, a positive and significant relationship between green patenting and firm performance was found for listed manufacturing firms in China for the 2000-2010 period, which revealed that green growth is mainly driven by green utility-model patents and that this positive relationship only exists among state-owned enterprises.
Abstract: This paper focuses on how green patenting influences a firm’s subsequent performance. By investigating listed manufacturing firms in China for the 2000–2010 period, we find a positive and significant relationship between green patenting and firm performance. Moreover, our research reveals that green growth is mainly driven by green utility-model patents and that this positive relationship only exists among state-owned enterprises (SOEs), which are more capable of leveraging green innovation through their close relationship with the government. Furthermore, the positive relationship is found to exist primarily after 2006, when the government began to provide formal legislative support to green industry.

523 citations

Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2018.11.006•
The composition, recycling and utilisation of Bayer red mud

[...]

M.A. Khairul1, Jafar Zanganeh1, Behdad Moghtaderi1•
University of Newcastle1
01 Feb 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this article, different methods and techniques have been suggested for the consumption of bulk red mud to maintain a sustainable environment, and an appropriate costbenefit analysis of the existing technologies needs to be examined in the future because of the high cost of the transportation of a large amount of red mud from alumina refineries to the point of application.
Abstract: Red mud or bauxite residue is a solid waste generated from the Bayer process. The disposal of red mud leads to a serious environmental threat because of its tiny particle size and high alkaline value. The utilisation and recycling of red mud is currently a crucial issue and needs to be addressed as soon as possible. This study demonstrates the different methods and techniques recently analysed or suggested for the consumption of bulk red mud to maintain a sustainable environment. The potential utilisations of red mud include valuable metal recovery, the preparation of construction materials and as an alternative catalyst for diverse processes, including hydrodechlorination, hydrogenation and hydrocarbon oxidation. In addition, the red mud can also be used to control environmental pollution, such as in wastewater treatment, soil remediation and the purification of flue gas. However, the proper utilisation and recycling of red mud has a number of shortcomings: pyro-metallurgical recovery involves high energy costs; large volumes of acid by-product needing to be neutralised after the leaching process; the fine particle size of red mud; and the necessity of pre-treatment in some methods. Although many studies have investigated the potential utilisation of red mud, most of them have concentrated on lab-scale studies. Therefore, a large-scale investigation of the recycling and utilisation of red mud needs to be explored. Moreover, an appropriate cost-benefit analysis of the existing technologies needs to be examined in the future because of the high cost of the transportation of a large amount of red mud from alumina refineries to the point of application.

478 citations

Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2019.03.024•
What influences an individual’s pro-environmental behavior? A literature review

[...]

Ding Li1, Luman Zhao1, Shuang Ma1, Shuang Ma2, Shuai Shao3, Lixiao Zhang4 •
Southwestern University of Finance and Economics1, Guangzhou University2, Shanghai University of Finance and Economics3, Beijing Normal University4
01 Jul 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: This article reviewed determinants of pro-environmental behavior on Resources Conservation and Recycling from 1987 to 2017 and found that the main factors which influence proenvironmental behaviour include both external and internal factors such as demographic variables and psychological factors.
Abstract: This review paper discusses determinants of pro-environmental behavior on Resources Conservation and Recycling from 1987 to 2017. The main factors which influence pro-environmental behavior include both external and internal factors—specifically, demographic variables and psychological factors. The main purpose of this work is to review the literature (i.e., published studies) regarding the impact, relations, and mutual effects on pro-environmental behavior of each group of factors. Identifying the determinants of pro-environmental behavior is helpful when formulating the most appropriate and effective policies for improving the public’s behavior toward protecting the natural environment.

451 citations

Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2018.10.006•
On the importance of sustainable human resource management for the adoption of sustainable development goals

[...]

Nour Chams1, Josep Garcia-Blandon•
Ramon Llull University1
01 Feb 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: A systematic literature review examines the key role of sustainable human resource management (SHRM) in developing a sustainable work environment and facilitating the attainment of sustainable development goals (SDGs) as discussed by the authors.
Abstract: Today, firms are becoming increasingly aware of the importance of social, ethical, and ecological objectives. In addition to financial profit, organizations are setting themselves new goals, focusing on individual, communal, and environmental-friendly performance and development. One of the disciplines that is promoting “green” organizations is Sustainable Human Resource Management (SHRM). Sustainable development goals (SDGs) are achieved through the adoption of new ecological techniques by the organization’s human capital and by the integration of innovative sustainable strategies. This systematic literature review examines the key role of SHRM in developing a sustainable work environment and in facilitating the attainment of SDGs. Based on a selection of empirical and conceptual articles, this review identifies the antecedents and outcomes of SHRM and highlights the obstacles to sustainable implementation not only at the level of the firm, but also from an international perspective. Four propositions are formulated that might be empirically tested in future studies. Research gaps in the existing literature are identified and potential future directions are suggested for further research in the field of sustainable management.

435 citations

Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2018.11.020•
Understanding consumers’ behavior intentions towards dealing with the plastic waste: Perspective of a developing country

[...]

Farhana Khan1, Waqar Ahmed1, Arsalan Najmi2, Arsalan Najmi1•
Iqra University1, University of Malaya2
01 Mar 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors identify the factors that influence the consumer's return/recycling intention regarding plastic waste and explore the recycling behavior of consumer, and find that return intention has positive significant impact on resell, reuse, dispose and donate, while reuse was the most predicted by the return intention.
Abstract: Plastic consumption has been increasing globally, creating large amount of litter and posing threat to the environment. The recycling of the plastic waste can help in reducing it and its environmental threat. The purpose of this paper is to identify the factors that influence the consumer’s return/recycling intention regarding plastic waste. Moreover, recycling behavior of consumer was explored in detail. The theory of planned behavior was adapted and extended to measure the determinants of recycling behavior. Survey research design was employed whereas data includes valid 243 households, collected through survey questionnaire, by employing purposive sampling. PLS-SEM was applied on the collected data for hypotheses testing. The finding of this study indicates that subjective norms, awareness consequences and convenience are major predictors of return/recycling intention. Whereas, hypothesis for the attitude, perceived behavioral control and moral norms were rejected and they all have insignificant impact on return/recycling intention. Moreover, return intention have positive significant impact on resell, reuse, dispose and donate. Reuse was the most predicted by the return intention. This study enriches the literature of reverse logistics helping to understand the consumers’ perspective. Provides the insights that will help government and organizations to understand consumers’ return/recycling intention and formulate such strategies that will increase the involvement of consumers in recycling activities.

374 citations

Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2018.10.004•
The effects of activated biochar addition on remediation efficiency of co-composting with contaminated wetland soil

[...]

Shujing Ye1, Guangming Zeng1, Haipeng Wu1, Jie Liang1, Chang Zhang1, Juan Dai1, Weiping Xiong1, Biao Song1, Shaohua Wu1, Jiangfang Yu1 •
Hunan University1
01 Jan 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this article, activated biochar was added for investigating the influences on physico-chemical properties of soil during composting, and the concentrations of available metals and arsenic in soil were detected on great reduction in the treatment of biochar-blended composting.
Abstract: Unreasonable disposal of organic wastes has caused great problems, including occupying land, affecting organoleptic feeling and causing environmental re-contamination. By incorporation of biochar as raw material into co-composting with agricultural organic matter, it not only can the wastes recycling be realized, but also can the remediation efficiency of multi-element contaminated soil be improved to reach land reclamation. Activated biochar was added for investigating the influences on physico-chemical properties of soil during composting. The concentrations of available metals and arsenic in soil were detected on great reduction in the treatment of biochar-blended composting. Based on the stronger adsorption and microbial activity induced by biochar, the initial content of available PAHs in wetland soil decreased to remain about 3.03% and 5.47% below the control (9.47%) in co-composting added with activated and fresh biochar, respectively. It was related to the observation with improved microbial number as well as optimized fungi/bacteria gene copy number ratio by activated biochar addition, which is conducive to vegetation replanting of contaminated land. The feasibility of applying biochar into co-composting with contaminated soil was confirmed by not only the high remediation efficiency but also the sustainable recycling of agricultural waste.

373 citations

Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2019.06.011•
Quantification of food waste per product group along the food supply chain in the European Union: a mass flow analysis

[...]

Carla Caldeira, Valeria De Laurentiis, Sara Corrado, Freija van Holsteijn, Serenella Sala 
01 Oct 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: A systematized food waste accounting at macro scale level was developed for Europe following Mass Flow Analysis concepts, ensuring closed mass balance.
Abstract: In 2015, the United Nations defined the Sustainable Development Goals (SDG), which include a target (12.3) on food waste. The target requires "by 2030, to halve per capita global food waste at the retail and consumer levels and to reduce food losses along production and supply chains, including post-harvest losses". The target has increased awareness about the food waste problem and boosted research in food waste quantification. Nevertheless, there is a lack of studies that adopt a systematic approach to account for food waste providing disaggregated values per food supply chain stage and per food groups. Such an approach could support policy makers in prioritizing interventions for food waste reduction. To fill this gap, this paper presents a high-level top-down approach to food waste accounting in the European Union. The study aims to support the understanding of the mass flows associated with food production, consumption, and waste, addressing different food groups along the food supply chain. The method for accountin is the mass flow analysis. According to the results, cereals, fruit, and vegetables as the food groups are responsible for the highest amount of food waste, and the consumption stage to be responsible for the largest share of food waste for most food groups. This work highlights the need for further primary research on food waste generation in the EU. Ultimately, this would allow to robustly estimate the food waste generated at EU level, and establishing a more accurate baseline to track the progress towards SDG target 12.3.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2018.10.041•
Recovery of precious metals from electronic waste and spent catalysts: A review

[...]

Yunji Ding1, Shengen Zhang1, Bo Liu1, Huandong Zheng1, Chein chi Chang2, Christian Ekberg3 •
University of Science and Technology Beijing1, District of Columbia Water and Sewer Authority2, Chalmers University of Technology3
01 Feb 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this paper, an overview of various technologies on the recovery of precious metals from e-waste and spent catalysts is provided, which shows that recycling technologies have been significantly improved in recent years.
Abstract: Precious metals are widely applied in many industry fields due to their excellent corrosion resistance, good electrical conductivity and high catalytic activity. However, the reserves of precious metals falls short of the production globally. The rapid generation of end-of-life products has become the significant resources of precious metals. Among these products, electronic waste (e-waste) and spent catalysts are more concentrated since they account for over 90% of precious metals in industry. This article provides an overview of various technologies on the recovery of precious metals from e-waste and spent catalysts. It shows that recycling technologies have been significantly improved in recent years. The recycling processes have transferred from leaching by aqua regia, cyanide and chlorine in acid solution to less pollution agents leaching. Environment-oriented technologies have been raised great attention in precious metals recycling. The advantages and environmental impacts of these recycling technologies have been discussed in detail. However, there are still some challenges for future promotion. In order to achieve the environment-friendly and sustainable recycling for precious metals with high recovery rate, several considerations have been proposed.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2018.10.031•
Utilization of red mud in road base and subgrade materials: A review

[...]

Emile Mukiza1, Lingling Zhang1, Xiaoming Liu1, Na Zhang2•
University of Science and Technology Beijing1, China University of Geosciences (Beijing)2
01 Feb 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this article, the possibility of utilizing red mud as a road base material, weak subgrade soil stabilizer as well as a subgrade material was discussed and it transpired that lime showed the best performance followed by dolime fine, ground granulated blast furnace slag, cement kiln dust and fly ash.
Abstract: Red mud is highly alkaline slurry produced during alumina extraction from bauxite. Its disposal generates serious environmental pollution. The best way to solve red mud disposal issues is to develop economic utilization technologies that consume significant amounts of red mud. This paper reviews the possibility of utilizing red mud as a road base material, weak subgrade soil stabilizer as well as a subgrade material. Results showed that red mud can be used for those purposes. It was also found that the stabilizing content needed to meet a certain standard differs due to differences in requirements from one country to another. Therefore, there is a need to design proportions with UCS, CBR, leaching characteristics required by the country in which red mud is intended for use. The effect of various stabilizers on performance of red mud is discussed and it transpired that lime showed the best performance followed by dolime fine, ground granulated blast furnace slag, cement kiln dust and fly ash. Findings indicated that red mud shows better performance as a subgrade material than natural soil. Also the synergistic use of red mud and other wastes also improves the mechanical and durability properties of the material compared with using red mud alone. Based on mechanical, economic and environmental benefits, it is recommended to use red mud in road base structure rather than in subgrade despite higher red mud consumption in subgrade than in road base. The scope for future research in this area is also suggested.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2019.01.024•
Food waste to biochars through pyrolysis: A review

[...]

Samar Elkhalifa1, Tareq Al-Ansari1, Hamish R. Mackey1, Gordon McKay1•
Korean Council for University Education1
01 May 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this article, the potential opportunities for food waste pyrolysis focusing on the conversion of food waste to biochar products were evaluated. But the authors did not consider the food waste composition and the process conditions.
Abstract: Waste generated from anthropogenic activities contributes toward stresses on our natural systems through impacts associated with both production and disposal. Sustainable waste management necessitates that industries shift from the current linear model to a circular based economy, utilizing wastes as raw materials for the production of new products, eg. fuels and chemicals. Biomass and associated waste materials can be converted into value-added products using thermochemical processes. The pyrolysis process is a convenient thermochemical method, whereby biomass is efficiently converted into biofuels, biochars and BBQ briquettes; and further processing yields additional value added products, such as activated carbons, carbon black and printing ink. This paper reviews current development work and evaluates potential opportunities for food waste pyrolysis focusing on the conversion of food waste to biochar products. Overall, it was found that the constituents of the food waste together with the process conditions play a major role in the yield and composition of the produced chars. Moreover, more research work needs to be conducted on food waste to biochar and on mixed food blends in particular.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2018.11.017•
Effect of Chinese policies on rare earth supply chain resilience

[...]

Nabeel A. Mancheri1, Nabeel A. Mancheri2, Benjamin Sprecher1, Gwendolyn Bailey2, Jianping Ge3, Arnold Tukker1 •
Leiden University1, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven2, China University of Geosciences (Beijing)3
01 Mar 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this article, the authors analyze the supply chain dynamics by specifically targeting a number of Chinese rare earths elements (REE) policies that have disruptive tendencies, focusing on how price responds to various resilience influencing mechanisms such as diversity of supply, regulatory frameworks and stockpiling.
Abstract: Rare earths elements (REE) are considered as strategic resources because they interact with business and governments’ direct policy interventions. Policy interventions can have a major effect on security of rare earth supply (Kooroshy et al., 2015). The purpose of this study is to scrutinize China’s REE policies and its impacts on the supply chain resilience. We analyze the supply chain dynamics by specifically targeting a number of Chinese REE policies that have disruptive tendencies. We analyze various policies placing the price at the center as an overarching feedback loop. In other words, we focus on how price responds to various resilience influencing mechanisms such as diversity of supply, regulatory frameworks, and stockpiling. In the process, we investigate Chinese influence on rest of the world (RoW) supply chain and dynamics inside the Chinese supply chain as there are two different layers of supply chain one for China and another one for rest of the world. We show that the supply chain is a complex phenomenon and resilience of a system is not solely dependent on physical disruptions but also on dynamic factors such as societal and geo-political (eg. environmental regulation, speculative market and export ban). We identify links and interdependencies even where data is not readily available and examine how the overall system reacts to various constraints and disruptions.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2019.01.042•
Sustainable use of Hermetia illucens insect biomass for feed and food: Attributional and consequential life cycle assessment

[...]

Sergiy Smetana1, Eric Schmitt, Alexander Mathys2•
German Institute of Food Technologies1, ETH Zurich2
01 May 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this paper, a life cycle assessment (LCA) of food industry side streams transformation via Hermetia illucens into intermediate products applicable for feed and food purposes is presented.
Abstract: The lack of protein sources in several parts of the world is triggering the search for locally produced and sustainable alternatives. Insect production is recognized as a potential solution. This study is a life cycle assessment (LCA) of food industry side streams transformation via Hermetia illucens into intermediate products applicable for feed and food purposes. It relies on attributional modelling for the estimation of the most impacting stages of insect production and on consequential modelling for the estimation of potential benefits or risks for the agri-food system. The consequential LCA included effects on the market, associated with upstream increase in feed (increase in commercial feed production) or downstream availability of insect product (substitution of fertilizer, protein concentrate for feed or chicken meat). Attributional and consequential LCAs are followed by sensitivity analyses, which identify the most promising directions towards sustainable insect production and estimate the magnitude of impact reductions if those directions are pursued by the industry. Analyses of the existing pilot process largely correspond with other findings in the literature, indicating fresh insect biomass is almost twice more sustainable than fresh chicken meat. Produced at pilot scale, protein concentrate (insect meal) while being competitive against animal-derived (whey, egg protein, fishmeal) and microalgae, has higher environmental impacts than plant-based meals. Further scenarios illustrate strategies for more sustainable use of environmental resources providing guidance for producers and funding agencies to direct the industry to an impact profile that is lower, than many existing protein sources.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2019.01.039•
Environmental behavior in a private-sphere context: Integrating theories of planned behavior and value belief norm, self-identity and habit

[...]

Anastasia Gkargkavouzi1, George Halkos1, Steriani Matsiori1•
University of Thessaly1
01 Sep 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this paper, an integrative model that includes the constructs from two theoretical frameworks, the theory of planned behavior (TPB) and the value belief norm theory (VBN), along with two additional variables, habits and self-identity, was proposed.
Abstract: This study explores the determinants of environmental behavior in a private-sphere context and proposes an integrative model that includes the constructs from two theoretical frameworks, the theory of planned behavior (TPB) and the value belief norm theory (VBN), along with two additional variables, habits and self-identity. A questionnaire survey method was used to collect the survey data and statistical analysis relied on application of structural equation modeling (SEM). The results show that intention is the best predictor of environmental behavior followed by habits and subjective norm is the main attendant of intention. Awareness of consequences has a positive impact on personal and subjective norms, attitudes and perceived behavioral control, while these constructs have in turn a significant influence on behavioral intention. Self-identity moderates the relationships between biospheric values and personal norm, attitudes, subjective norm, and perceived behavioral control. The proposed model exhibit superior predictive ability compared to the original TPB and VBN models verifying its utility and effectiveness in explaining environmental behavior. The results of this work can be used by governments and policymakers to design and implement conservation programs to promote a more sustainable lifestyle. Recommendations for future research are discussed in the last section of this paper.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2018.10.010•
The process of peak CO2 emissions in developed economies: A perspective of industrialization and urbanization

[...]

Feng Dong1, Ying Wang1, Bin Su2, Yifei Hua1, Yuanqing Zhang1 •
China University of Mining and Technology1, National University of Singapore2
01 Feb 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this paper, the impacts of urbanization and industrialization on carbon emissions were examined by using a threshold regression model, and the results indicated that urbanization has a significant double-threshold effect on carbon emission.
Abstract: The experiences of peak carbon emissions in developed economies can provide a significant reference for other economies. In terms of peak carbon intensity, per capita carbon emissions and carbon emissions, the peak process in developed economies is divided into three stages. This study analyzes gross domestic product (GDP), per capita GDP, industrialization rate, urbanization rate, and other indicators in each stage. The impacts of urbanization and industrialization on carbon emissions are examined by using a threshold regression model. The results indicate that urbanization and income level have a significant double-threshold effect on carbon emissions. From the perspective of urbanization, there is no significant correlation between carbon emissions and urbanization in the low-urbanization stage. However, urbanization has a negative effect on carbon emissions in the mid-urbanization stage. Then, this inhibitory effect becomes a promotional effect when the urbanization level crosses the second threshold. From the perspective of income level, industrialization contributes to the growth of carbon emissions. The promotional effect of industrialization on carbon emissions gradually increases in the low and intermediate income levels. However, this promotional effect begins to weaken in the high income level. Our study not only extends the existing literature about peak carbon emissions, but also merits particular attention for policy makers in less developed economies.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2018.09.016•
Mapping Industrial Symbiosis Development in Europe_ typologies of networks, characteristics, performance and contribution to the Circular Economy

[...]

Teresa Domenech1, Raimund Bleischwitz1, Asel Doranova, Dimitris Panayotopoulos1, Laura Roman •
University College London1
01 Feb 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors provide an overview of industrial symbiosis in Europe, with a mapping of key networks, and a study of prevailing typologies of networks, size, geographical distribution and main streams/ resources traded.
Abstract: Last years have seen a surge of Industrial Symbiosis (IS) development in association with ad-hoc widespread policies to encourage more circular and sustainable practices in the manufacturing sector. Developments in Europe, despite having attracted less attention in the literature, have been significant, driven both by public and private initiative. This paper provides an updated overview of IS activity in Europe, with a mapping of key networks, and a study of prevailing typologies of networks, size, geographical distribution and main streams/ resources traded. The analysis is based on a combination of desk research, gathering of primary data from case studies, a survey to IS network facilitators (n = 22) and in-depth interviews and focus groups (3) with IS practitioners, policy officers and industry representatives (n = 25). The analysis identified pockets of IS activity across all Europe, although varying in nature, resources exchanged and scale and scope of the initiatives. The average size of the mapped networks is approx. 473 members, but the median is approx. 100 members, which indicates high variability of sizes. The geographical scope of the synergies also seems to be dependent upon the following factors: 1) the type of waste stream/by-product; 2) transport costs and 3) market value of secondary materials. Types of waste streams exchanged common to most networks, are chemicals (e.g. chemical base products), biomass and agriculture by-products, wood and wood pellets, plastics, reusable construction materials, equipment, inert waste and water (different qualities including industrial water), residual heat and steam. The paper also discusses key obstacles facing IS development in Europe highlighting: 1) weakness of economic incentives given the low margin of IS projects associated to undeveloped secondary markets; 2) geographical variation of incentives and drivers, given differences in policy frameworks and support mechanisms (e.g. landfill tax levels) and 3) legislative issues that make transport over geographic boundaries extremely complex and administratively burdensome. Finally, the paper concludes with a general discussion of the potential of IS to contribute to the transition to the circular economy (CE) in Europe and identifies some key areas of future research.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2018.11.018•
Food-energy-water (FEW) nexus for urban sustainability: A comprehensive review

[...]

Pengpeng Zhang1, Lixiao Zhang1, Yuan Chang2, Ming Xu3, Yan Hao1, Sai Liang1, Gengyuan Liu1, Zhifeng Yang1, Can Wang4 •
Beijing Normal University1, Central University of Finance and Economics2, University of Michigan3, Tsinghua University4
01 Mar 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this article, the authors provide a comprehensive literature review to debate the current concepts and methods of the food, energy, and water (FEW) nexus at different scales, with the aim of developing a conceptual knowledgebase framework for scientific analysis and policy making associated with the urban FEW nexus.
Abstract: The emerging popularity of the nexus discussion reflects the ongoing transition from a sectoral or silo approach to an integrative approach to address the global challenges pertinent to the three essential resources: food, energy, and water (FEW). Cities are critically important for advancing regional sustainable development and are thus placed at the center of the FEW nexus. This paper provides a comprehensive literature review to debate the current concepts and methods of the FEW nexus at different scales, with the aim of developing a conceptual knowledgebase framework for scientific analysis and policy making associated with the urban FEW nexus. Although the concept of nexus thinking has been widely accepted, a consistent and explicit cognition of the FEW nexus is still lacking, and a sophisticated methodological modeling framework is urgently required at various scales. As such, we proposed a three-dimensional conceptual framework of the urban FEW nexus from the perspective of resource interdependency, resource provision and system integration. This framework is useful in steering the systematic modeling and integrative management of the complex nexus issues of urban systems with different perspectives. Finally, the future directions of urban nexus research are identified from four aspects, including systematic characterization, cross-region tele-connection mechanisms, co-decision model development, and governance transition.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2018.10.013•
Exploring young adults’ e-waste recycling behaviour using an extended theory of planned behaviour model: A cross-cultural study

[...]

Anita Kumar1•
Coventry University1
01 Feb 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: The authors explored young adults' e-waste recycling behavior cross-culturally using an extended Theory of planned Behaviour (TPB) model and found that the key influencing factors that influenced recycling behavior amongst young adults were: attitude (moderated by a sense of duty), perceived control, subjective norm and individual responsibility whereas Convenience and Consequences Awareness constructs did not have significant influence.
Abstract: The objective of this research is to explore young adults’ e-waste recycling behaviour cross-culturally using an extended Theory of planned Behaviour (TPB) model. The results of a survey involving respondents from the two culturally-distinct emerging markets showed that the key influencing factors that influenced e-waste recycling behaviour amongst young adults were: Attitude (moderated by a Sense of Duty), Perceived Control, Subjective Norm and Individual Responsibility whereas Convenience and Consequences Awareness constructs did not have significant influence. Cross-cultural differences were also evident as stronger relationships were witnessed for Perceived Control and Subjective Norm constructs for the Chinese young adults’ intention to recycle e-waste. The reverse was found to be true for Attitude (moderated by a Sense of Duty) and Individual Responsibility constructs where stronger relationships were observed in the Indian sample. This research makes a valuable theoretical contribution as it is positioned at the intersection of cross-cultural studies, sustainability and reverse supply chain management areas. This study has practical implication at two levels: the individual actor level and the supply chain level as consumers’ intentions to recycle, underpinned by responsibility towards environment, directly impact the performance of reverse supply chains.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2019.02.010•
LCA of plastic waste recovery into recycled materials, energy and fuels in Singapore

[...]

Hsien H. Khoo
01 Jun 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this paper, alternative solutions are introduced to address the waste problem, such as recovering valuable fuels from plastics via thermochemical methods, and the results demonstrated how different combinations of four plastics valorization technologies, and associated capacities, affected the potential environmental benefits and drawbacks of plastic waste treatment systems.
Abstract: In Singapore, 822,200 tonnes of plastic waste was generated in 2016, with only 7% recycled. Due to the complex nature of plastic waste mixtures, mechanical recycling is often inefficient, leading to a majority of waste being incinerated. In this article, alternative solutions are introduced to address the waste problem, such as recovering valuable fuels from plastics via thermochemical methods. Life cycle assessment (LCA) was adopted to investigate 8 scenarios of plastic waste management options. In a nation with land scarcity, the scales and sizes of each plastic waste recycling/recovery method is also taken into consideration. The results demonstrated how different combinations of four plastics valorization technologies, and associated capacities, affected the potential environmental benefits and drawbacks of plastic waste treatment systems. In order to enable selecting the best option among the 8 scenarios, normalization and weighting was carried out.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2019.05.015•
Total material requirement for the global energy transition to 2050: A focus on transport and electricity

[...]

Takuma Watari1, Takuma Watari2, Benjamin McLellan1, Damien Giurco2, Elsa Dominish2, Eiji Yamasue3, Keisuke Nansai4, Keisuke Nansai5 •
Kyoto University1, University of Technology, Sydney2, Ritsumeikan University3, National Institute for Environmental Studies4, University of Sydney5
01 Sep 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this article, the authors demonstrate a systematic model that can quantify resource flows of both minerals and energy resources under the energy transition by using stock-flow dynamics and the concept of Total Material Requirement (TMR).
Abstract: Global energy transitions could fundamentally change flows of both minerals and energy resources over time. It is, therefore, increasingly important to holistically and dynamically capture the impacts of large-scale energy transitions on resource flows including hidden flows such as mine waste, as well as direct flows. Here we demonstrate a systematic model that can quantify resource flows of both minerals and energy resources under the energy transition by using stock-flow dynamics and the concept of Total Material Requirement (TMR). The proposed model was applied to the International Energy Agency’s scenarios up to 2050, targeting 15 electricity generation and 5 transport technologies. Results indicate that the global energy transition could increase TMR flows associated with mineral production by around 200–900% in the electricity sector and 350–700% in the transport sector respectively from 2015 to 2050, depending on the scenarios. Such a drastic increase in TMR flows is largely associated with an increased demand for copper, silver, nickel, lithium and cobalt, as well as steel. Our results highlight that the decarbonization of the electricity sector can reduce energy resource flows and support the hypothesis that the expansion of low-carbon technologies could reduce total resource flows expressed as TMR. In the transport sector, on the other hand, the dissemination of Electric Vehicles could cause a sharp increase in TMR flows associated with mineral production, which could offset a decrease in energy resource flows. Findings in this study emphasize that a sustainable transition would be unachievable without designing resource cycles with a nexus approach.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2019.104479•
Public attitudes towards bioplastics – knowledge, perception and end-of-life management

[...]

Leela Dilkes-Hoffman1, Peta Ashworth1, Bronwyn Laycock1, Steven Pratt1, Paul Lant1 •
University of Queensland1
01 Dec 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: For example, the authors found that the Australian public's knowledge of bioplastics is low, but perception of biodegradable plastics is positive, with 62% of those who use bioplastic items disposing of them in the recycling bin feeling that they would be better for the environment than normal plastics.
Abstract: The aim of this research was to understand current knowledge and perceptions regarding bioplastics. Results were gathered through an online survey of 2518 nationally representative Australians. The results indicate that the Australian public’s knowledge of bioplastics is low, but perception, particularly of biodegradable plastics, is positive. Biodegradable plastics were perceived as better for the environment than ‘normal plastics’ and even ‘easily recyclable’ plastics. The majority of respondents (58%) said they were unsure whether biodegradable plastics can have negative environmental impacts. Sixty-eight percent of people say they would like to see more of the plastic items they use be biodegradable. If this becomes the case, there will be an increased stream of bioplastics entering the recycling system with 62% of people saying they would dispose of bioplastic items in the recycling bin. In light of the results presented in this work, potential issues relating to the introduction of bioplastics are raised and the role that governments and local councils can play in driving the development of the standards, labelling and waste management options that will need to be introduced alongside the introduction of wider bioplastic materials use are discussed.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2019.06.005•
Green innovation: Unfolding the relation with environmental regulations and competitiveness

[...]

Jaluza Maria Lima Silva Borsatto1, Jaluza Maria Lima Silva Borsatto2, Lara Bartocci Liboni Amui1•
University of São Paulo1, Federal University of Uberlandia2
01 Oct 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this paper, the degree of severity of environmental regulations and the international competitiveness of the countries affects the efforts in green innovation of companies of the industrial sector of Developed Countries (MEDC) and developing countries (LEDC).
Abstract: The present study intends to analyze how the degree of severity of environmental regulations and the international competitiveness of the countries affects the efforts in Green Innovation (GI) of companies of the industrial sector of Developed Countries (MEDC) and developing countries (LEDC). The survey sample consisted of 186 industrial companies, which are listed in the Financial Times' top 500 companies by market value in 2015, of which 114 were MEDC and 72 were LEDC. For the analysis, we used Structural Equation Modeling to verify the relationship between the variables. The main results were, among the antecedents of the green innovation analyzed, the rigor of the environmental regulations of the countries and the size of the companies had a statistically significant positive impact of the industrial enterprises of the MEDC and LEDC only in the IV2 construct, composed of the variables Global Compact and environmental investments. The competitiveness of the countries did not have a positive influence on the GI effort of the companies, and the Degree of Internationalization of companies has not had a significant effect on any of the GI constructs. Moreover, the results also showed that the relationship between environmental regulation and GI is moderated positively by the size of the companies and moderated negatively by the degree of internationalization, and the relation between the competitiveness of the countries and GI is negatively moderated by the size of the companies and moderated positively by its degree of internationalization. Although there is a prevailing view that environmental regulations provide a greater effort on the part of companies with green innovation, in this study it was verified that this relation can be positive or negative, and can also be modified by external factors such as size and the degree of internationalization of companies.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2019.104459•
Global environmental losses of plastics across their value chains

[...]

Morten Ryberg1, Michael Zwicky Hauschild1, Feng Wang, Sandra Averous-Monnery, Alexis Laurent1 •
Technical University of Denmark1
01 Dec 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors make a global estimation of the losses of plastics to the environment across the entire plastic value chain, using existing literature and databases coupled with improved and additional methodological modelling of losses.
Abstract: With the increasing focus on marine plastic pollution, quantification of the environmental losses of plastics in the world, with differentiation into geographic regions, polymers and loss occurrences along the plastics value chains, is required. In this study, we make a global estimation of the losses of plastics to the environment across the entire plastic value chain, using existing literature and databases coupled with improved and additional methodological modelling of the losses. The resulting loss estimates are unprecedented in their detailed differentiations between polymers (23), plastic applications (13), geographical regions (11), and plastic value chain stages. Comprehensive sensitivity and uncertainty analyses were also conducted to identify key drivers in terms of plastic losses. We overall found that approximately 6.2 Mt (95% confidence interval, CI: 2.0–20.4 Mt) of macroplastics and 3.0 Mt (CI: 1.5–5.2 Mt) of microplastics were lost to the environment in 2015. The major macroplastic loss source was identified as the mismanaged municipal solid waste (MSW) management in low-income and lower-middle income countries (4.1 Mt). For microplastics, the major sources were abrasion of tyre rubbers, abrasion of road markings and plastics contributing to city dust generation. To curb marine plastic pollution, such quantified mapping as ours are needed to evaluate the magnitude of the plastics losses to environment from different sources and locations, and enable a further assessment of their environmental damage. Through our uncertainty and sensitivity analyses, we highlight plastics sources that should be prioritized in further research works to obtain a more comprehensive and accurate representation of global plastics losses.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2018.09.021•
Investigation on decision-making mechanism of residents’ household solid waste classification and recycling behaviors

[...]

Xiaoyan Meng1, Xianchun Tan1, Yi Wang1, Zongguo Wen2, Yuan Tao3, Yi Qian2 •
Chinese Academy of Sciences1, Tsinghua University2, University of Cambridge3
01 Jan 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: Wang et al. as mentioned in this paper investigated the decision-making mechanism of residents' HSW disposal behaviors by merging the theory of planned behavior and the Attitude-Behavior-Condition theory and found that residents' behavioral selection has been significantly related to four intrinsic subjective factors and seven external objective factors, and the combined effect of the latter ones is nearly twice of that of the former ones.
Abstract: Residents’ participation in classification and recycling of urban household solid waste (HSW) is a critical factor for the success of municipal solid waste management. The aim of this study is to investigate the decision-making mechanism of residents’ HSW disposal behaviors by merging the theory of planned behavior and the Attitude-Behavior-Condition theory. In this study, based on the survey data of 709 residents in Suzhou, China and structural equation modeling method, the main factors that affect residents’ HSW disposal behaviors and their degree of influence were analyzed, followed by discussion on decision-making mechanisms. The findings show that residents’ behavioral selection has been significantly related to four intrinsic subjective factors and seven external objective factors, and the combined effect of the latter ones is nearly twice of that of the former ones. Moreover, the convenient of environmental facilities and services are most effective at promoting residents’ participation in HSW classification and recycling. Specifically, the observed variables of publicity and education, accessibility to recycling facilities, accessibility to classification facilities, willingness to participation of classification and residents' environmental awareness are the five most significant factors. The impact of laws and regulations is not significant; however, this may be because that there was no mandatory laws, regulations and incentive mechanisms on HSW classification and recycling in Suzhou in this period, and there is still a big gap and room for improvement in this aspect in mainland China. Finally, the study put forward relevant policy recommendations for the comprehensive management of urban HSW classification and recycling.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2018.10.036•
Circular building materials: Carbon saving potential and the role of business model innovation and public policy

[...]

Julia L.K. Nußholz1, Freja Nygaard Rasmussen, Leonidas Milios1•
International Institute of Minnesota1
01 Feb 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this article, a comparative case study of three pioneering Scandinavian companies that produce circular building materials was conducted to estimate the carbon saving potential of using secondary material, and business model innovations to implement strategies, and companies' experienced and desired policies to help remove barriers.
Abstract: Buildings are responsible for a third of global greenhouse gas emissions, with much of their life cycle impacts stemming from embodied impacts of building materials. Both at EU and Member State level, circular economy and resource efficiency policies are promoting production of lower-impact building materials with secondary material input. However, secondary material strategies do not result in carbon saving by default, and depend on businesses developing effective and economic applications that can overcome the many barriers to closing material loops. This paper aims to advance understanding of the relevance of secondary material for decarbonisation of the building sector, as well as the interplay of business model innovation and policy instruments in this transition. We used a comparative case study of three pioneering Scandinavian companies that produce circular building materials to estimate the carbon saving potential of using secondary material. We also examined business model innovations to implement strategies, and companies’ experienced and desired policies to help remove barriers. The results show clearly that all three cases offer potential for carbon savings. As the savings vary significantly, findings suggest that careful consideration of affected processes and markets is a key to attaining carbon savings. Business model innovations to enable secondary material use involve establishing key partnerships to access secondary materials, developing recovery process and technology, targeting customer segments that value lower environmental impacts, and considering life cycle costs. Public policies that can help companies remove barriers include 1) incorporating reuse of higher material value in construction and demolition waste targets, and 2) incentivising waste collection and recovery markets to offer recovered material at higher value.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2018.10.011•
Biodiversity and the built environment: Implications for the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)

[...]

Alex Opoku1•
University College London1
01 Feb 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors examine the link between the Built Environment, Biodiversity and the Sustainable Development Goals and explore the role of a sustainable built environment towards biodiversity conservation which is central to the realisation of the SDGs in general and SDG 15 in particular.
Abstract: Recent major global environmental initiatives toward a more sustainable society are the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), the New Urban Agenda (NUA) and the Paris Agreement. The built environment has been recognised as a major contributor to loss of biodiversity and should therefore play a major role in a sustainable world where ecological values are enhanced. There should be a smooth interaction between the built environment and the natural environment because humanity and nature are the usual victims of loss of biodiversity. The purpose of this paper is to examine the link between the Built Environment, Biodiversity and the Sustainable Development Goals. The paper explores the role of a sustainable built environment towards biodiversity conservation which is central to the realisation of the SDGs in general and SDG 15 in particular. The paper adopts a qualitative research methodology using knowledge generation workshop involving 16 experts from both academia and industry. The results show that, even though the built environment has a negative impact on biodiversity, it also has the greatest opportunity to integrate biodiversity into all development projects. Reducing the impact of the built environment on biodiversity should be an integral part of policies and strategies towards a sustainable built environment. All key built environment stakeholders need to engage in raising awareness of the effects of biodiversity loss as a result of construction activities, on the health and wellbeing of mankind. The value of this paper is to help decision-makers such as government agencies, industry-players and non-governmental organisations to understand the contributions of the built environment towards biodiversity conservation in achieving the SDGs.
Journal Article•10.1016/J.RESCONREC.2018.10.002•
Coupling material circularity indicators and life cycle based indicators: A proposal to advance the assessment of circular economy strategies at the product level

[...]

Monia Niero1, Pradip P. Kalbar2•
Aalborg University1, Indian Institute of Technology Bombay2
01 Jan 2019-Resources Conservation and Recycling
TL;DR: It is demonstrated that by coupling different types of indicators via Multi Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) it is possible to deal with conflicting situations where the selection of the best alternative can be biased by the choice of the metric.
Abstract: The debate on the identification of the most suited metrics for circular economy (CE) is open, no consensus has been reached yet on what CE indicators at product level should measure, which creates a subjective methodological framework for assessing CE strategies. In this study, we demonstrate that by coupling different types of indicators via Multi Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) it is possible to deal with conflicting situations where the selection of the best alternative can be biased by the choice of the metric. We use a beer packaging case, by simulating a situation where a company is interested in comparing the performances of different packaging from a CE perspective. We consider eight different beer packaging alternatives in two geographical contexts (United Kingdom and India). Two sets of indicators are coupled via MCDA: i) material circularity based- indicators, namely Material Reutilization Score and Material Circularity Indicator, and ii) a selection of life cycle based- indicators relevant for beer, i.e. climate change, abiotic resource depletion, acidification, particulate matter and water consumption. The results obtained by the application of the TOPSIS (Technique for Order by Similarity to Ideal Solution) method show that the different sets of indicators can be integrated and conflicts among them can be resolved. Overall, the application of different weighting scenarios does not change the ranking of the alternatives, thus confirming that the results are stable. Therefore, our proposal of coupling material circularity indicators with LCA indicators via MCDA can advance the assessment of CE strategies at the product level.
...

Tools

SciSpace AgentBiomedical AgentSciSpace RecruitSciSpace for EnterpriseAgent GalleryChat with PDFLiterature ReviewAI WriterFind TopicsParaphraserCitation GeneratorExtract DataAI DetectorCitation Booster

Learn

ResourcesLive Workshops

SciSpace

CareersSupportBrowse PapersPricingSciSpace Affiliate ProgramCancellation & Refund PolicyTermsPrivacyData Sources

Directories

PapersTopicsJournalsAuthorsConferencesInstitutionsCitation StylesWriting templates

Extension & Apps

SciSpace Chrome ExtensionSciSpace Mobile App

Contact

support@scispace.com
SciSpace

© 2026 | PubGenius Inc. | Suite # 217 691 S Milpitas Blvd Milpitas CA 95035, USA

soc2
Secured by Delve